patching...
Breaking: Super 8 Hotel Patron Burglarized Guest Rooms, Police Allege »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Three Mahwah Schools Performing At Below-Proficient Levels

Board hires tutors, recommends hiring new teachers to raise test scores

 

The Mahwah school district will be taking measures to improve students’ test scores because “scores on state assessments are simply not terrific,” interim Superintendent Dr. Karen Lake said at Wednesday night’s school board meeting. Three of the district’s six schools did not meet their “Adequate Yearly Progress,” or AYP goals, and one school – Joyce Kilmer – has not been able to reach those standards for four years.

For state exams like the NJASK, “the state sets the bar as to what scores are proficient, above that and below,” Lake explained. “Some of our schools came in with too high a percentage of students scoring below the proficiency level.”

According to results released by the state last month, nearly 37 percent of third grade students at Lenape Meadows were not proficient in Language Arts. This was the highest concentration of below-proficient scores in any one grade level, however Lake said certain scores at Joyce Kilmer and Ramapo Ridge Middle School also did not make the grade.

Mahwah’s scores are still mostly higher than the state average, but Lake said when comparing the district’s test score results with those of other districts similar to Mahwah, “our kids are not performing at the level they should be.”

Lake said the district is starting to take measures now to improve students’ understanding of “basic skills.” The board approved Wednesday night hiring tutors to provide additional assistance to Mahwah students. “The board should be commended for this. Seeing there was an issue, the board took the high road and hired the help we needed,” Lake said.

The interim head of the district is also recommending several additions to staffing throughout the district. Most of the positions she’s recommending “address pockets of need that have been growing in the district,” she said. The recommendations include an ESL, or English as a Second Language, teacher and two special education teachers.

Lake said she is also recommending the district hire three reading teachers/literacy coaches. “The coaches would teach the teachers how to be more effective, and would improve instruction to our kids,” she said. Coaches are “common” among Bergen County districts, she said.

Her hiring recommendations also include a first grade teacher at Lenape Meadows, a math/science teacher at the high school, a part-time business teacher at the high school, and a director of curriculum.

According to Lake, the district’s administrative staff has been trimmed too much, and the lack of an overall curriculum coordinator to oversee all that is taught in the district is a “problem. We have an overarching responsibility to keep our curriculum current.” According to Lake, committees at each school currently develop curricula independently of one another.

All of the staffing recommendations are based on student and program needs, Lake said.

“We can’t ignore this, because the younger kids that are not where they should be [in terms of test scores] will get older, go to high school and need to pass higher level exams. It is our job to work on weaknesses, and provide remediation.”

The staffing recommendations made Wednesday will be considered by the school board over the next month, and final decisions on whether or not the district will hire these or other positions will be made by the end of the month.

According to Business Administrator Ed Deptula, a $400K bump in state aid the district received this year will help pay for the additional positions. “But, we should be OK going forward, whether we continue to get that aid or not. We don’t want to start something and then not be able to sustain it two years down the road.”

Lake said Mahwah is "still a great district. It is not a bad thing to identify areas of need, and fix them. That's what we are trying to do."

See all of Mahwah’s 2010-2011 test results here.

Related Topics: Mahwah Education and Mahwah Schools

fastharry

9:52 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

If Parents would start parenting, and administrators would start doing their jobs, and everyone would just let teachers teach, test scores would rise.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Traci

1:31 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

I agree!!! Parents and teachers need to be a united front to help the child learn. When I grew up, they worked like this and I grew up fine..... (lol) You can't have the child complaining, the teacher doesn't like me, the teacher this and that and then the parent call the teacher yelling. This prevents the end results... Your child's education!!!

jeanne

11:25 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

Amazing everyone is Mahwah needs a tutor, now I am glad to see the school will be getting tutors as well to save us parents from paying for them. The curriculums they use are confusing. Everyday Math has been dropped by many area schools, for the fact it just is to confusing to the children. The simply cant do regular problem solving. Drill basic facts into there heads, not the in and outs and back and fourths of this current math program. Go back to what has worked for years, the old method you will see the results you want to see and the children and parents will be happiers as well.

Reply
Comment_arrow

abm

5:49 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

If you look closely at the math scores, those are significantly better than the language arts scores, so that means EDM is working. I teach EDM in another district and can vouch for the value, if properly taught, of the program. Training in the "tricks of the EDM" trade as well as parent education of how the program works makes a world of difference and is worth the investment. Stick with what works. Your perspective probably comes from a fear of something different. Be open-minded!

Comment_arrow

concerned mom

10:52 am on Friday, March 9, 2012

You're right - it seems as if everyone in Mahwah needs tutors, and lucky for us, the teachers in town here charge us a "measly" $70.00 + per hour to teach them outside of school what they're not teaching them in school!! So whos winning here? It definitely isnt the children or the parents....

Comment_arrow

Traci

1:36 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

You are absolutely right Jeanne!!! You need to teach the basics and get a firm understanding of those, before introducing algebra. My child is in the 4th grade and has learned algebra. They do not have the basics down!!! How can they figure out what # equals x, when they can't figure out what 6 X 8 is without taking 4 minutes to figure it out. We had to memorize the multiplication tables up to 12. I don't see where they are doing this anymore. What is lattice multiplication? You can't figure that out, what happened to long division and multiplication? You had to show the work. I try to help with homework and my kids tell me that I did it wrong. Well???

Nick

11:58 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

I don't know what to make of everyday math. My daughter struggled with it despite having some excellent teachers in the lower grades through 5th grade. Oddly enough, she always tested advanced proficient, even though it seemed like she didn't get it. This year everything sort of clicked, and she's doing very well. I find that the English/reading/writing has been lacking over the past few years. I work extensively with my daughter on how to write essays, punctuation, etc. It seems like grammar is a lost art in the schools. I think it has more to do with the curriculum than the teachers, based on conversations that I've had with teachers that I know in other districts that deal with similar issues.

I also see a political side of this story due to the ongoing impasse in contract negotiations with the teachers.

Reply
Comment_arrow

mahwah mom

12:56 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

Nick,
The reading/writing/English has been lacking in the Mahwah school. I have no problem with the teachers. My child is getting straight A's yet is struggling to read. We need to change the way the reading program is structured to support the kids. When I was young, if you did not do well, you were left back. Today holding a child back is extremely rare, sometimes it is done only after the parent fights with the school (can you believe that!!) Administration wants all children to "feel good about themselves". I don't know about the rest of the residents, but I am feeling more than a little uncomfortable with the state of the Mahwah School. The reading program is a "house of cards" and I don't think the blame lies with the teachers. I am unhappy with the reading program but have a hard time accepting that any teacher would hold back with a child because a contract is not finalized. Teachers are instructed to follow a model and don't see the child that they taught fall on their faces academically because it takes a couple of years before the child is "not proficient". We as parents must insist the "reading model" be changed!

Comment_arrow

Nick

1:06 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

mahwah mom,

I've had a different experience with the schools. My daughter went to Lenape and has always been an avid reader. She joined the book club at Lenape in 2nd grade (which the 2nd grade teachers ran on their own time) ... and always received the support she needed. We've always encouraged reading at home, as well. I've had concerns about writing and grammar skills. So we work on that together at home.

MOMX3

1:19 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

Two words: READING PROGRAM??????????

Reply

Stay

1:37 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

The teachers can have an amazing impact on scores. My kids had a
teacher in the 9th grade last year. I'm pretty sure he was new to the school. He is an incredible teacher and I wish the schools had dozens more like him. He taught them well and prepared them even better for the standard testing. Proficient is a fairly low grade (I think in the 70's). My kids were always proficient in English. One of them was just over the line to advanced proficient but they both got above 96% on the English last year. I never saw this from them before. The best part is that they weren't taught just for the test but they actually learned a lot and now are so much better in English because of this on teacher.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Traci

1:41 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

I agree with Stay, the teachers most certainly do have an effect on how the child learns. My child has a great teacher for math and science this year, that is really fun to listen to and his teaching has a fun approach. I think all teachers should realize that if the are fun and not just speaking to "teach" the lesson, the kids would absorb it more. My daughter getting A's in that science class, because of this teacher.

Kim

2:08 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

IMHO...Get the govt out of our schools! They've created a monster in which we have teachers teaching for test results instead of teaching for the sake of actual learning. Teachers need to be able to do what they do best and not be forced to follow govt mandates. Our kids would all be better off in the long run.

Reply

Edward G. Modica

2:41 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

As a retired teacher from Allendale, I can assure you that the Mahwah teachers have not lowered their high expectations for student success, or their admirable work ethics due to the impasse in contract negotiations~! I know many of the staff members in Mahwah, and I believe that their methodology and teaching practices are worthy of emulation by their peers~!
The problem begins and ends with Governor Christie~! He has blatantly attempted to destroy the process of education in New Jersey~! His attack on public school employees is a disgrace and must be addressed by all taxpayers~! Why is it that we have a silent majority and a vocal minority in our state~? We, the taxpayers, are responsible for the success or failure in our schools~! Speak out, and be heard~! Tell the Governor that our schools cannot function properly without sufficient funding~! Staffing cuts hurt the children, and ultimately, their abilities to perform successfully~!
The Mahwah teaching staff has long held a reputation for being among the best in the state~! That does not change overnight~! I would like to personally thank them for all of their dedication and hard work~!

Reply
Comment_arrow

concerned mom

11:11 am on Friday, March 9, 2012

Edward, Do you have any of your own children currently in our schools here? No offense, but if you don't, you really can't comment on the system here in town. MOMX3 is right - there is NO reading program in place here - which has nothing to do with our governor - and it SHOULD be starting in kindergarten! And now we have this horrendous Word Wisdom which is the worst thing to have come into our schools. Our children are learning NOTHING from it!!! This is not a place for you to air your democratic beliefs, but hopefully a place to be honest about the problems here in our town's school system that are a result of our own school administrators!! Lets be honest here, put your defensive mode aside about blaming everyone but the teachers, and lets help the children here!!

Mpl

3:37 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

How about not having so many days off??? All summer, every month is a holiday or single session. Everyone needs to put more time in since it's apparent the time now is not sufficient. !!

Reply

MOMX3

4:22 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

This is not a political issue, it's a issue with the k-3 curriculum...If you don't have a READING program in place for every child- every classroom- then when you test kids on reading comprehension and language arts they WILL fail. We shouldn't need extra tutors or coaches. Our teachers are fantastic and fully capable when given the right curriculum.

Reply

Bob Rama

4:29 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

This article is kind of worthless with knowing BY HOW MUCH they didn't meet their goals by. How much better did the other schools perform on their AYP? Because I don't see the high school mentioned at all. It seems to me the moral of the report is by the time students get to the high school testing they are ready and prepared to take those tests. Am I interpreting that wrong? I am also confused that Dr. Lake not too long ago praised the district for their test scores and now is slamming the district because scores aren't good enough. Which is it? Improving test scores is going to take a team effort from teachers, parents, administrators and students. It doesn't seem Dr. Lake gives that concept credence in her quotes here. Also, any contract negotiation updates from last night?

Reply

mahwah mom

5:56 am on Friday, March 9, 2012

If the children are not given reading comprehension in the early years of school K-3, they are at great disadvantage. If your child only brings home vocabulary and a limited amount of reading comprehension BEWARE!!! The reading program in Mahwah leaves much to be desired. The children in K-3 should be bringing home reading worksheets with questions about the text on a daily basis, ruberics, and writing assignments. If you suspect that your child has reading difficulties, take them out of district to be tested. Mae Balaban in Teaneck is a wonderful center. If you identify specific learning weaknesses the school must address the issues. The school must be accountable but parents must also be an active participant in their child's education. I am so glad to see this article, the school needs to put a better reading program in place for our children. Don't wait for the teachers to tell you your child is at a disadvantage, they are afraid of administration!!!!

Reply

Traci

1:44 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

The district is going to hire tutors etc. Who is going to end of paying for this???? It will be the tax payers - the parents.

Reply

Bret Barnaby

9:28 pm on Friday, March 9, 2012

I hear, and tend to believe, that the problem is not in the schools but more of parents being absent parents. Not all of them but a majority, sadly enough. If your child is struggling with reading or math, do YOU spend the extra time per night going the extra mile for YOUR childs or do your whine that it must be the teachers fault? When is it the parents fault? When I struggled in school, my mother met with the teacher face to face and did not email back and forth and hope for a solution. I salute those parents who take the responsibility to parent your child as opposed to just hoping they get what they need and if they dont, you'll still take your spring break a week early..the same week that could focus on NJASK. But take the easy way out, blame everyone else except that one person who you see in the mirror!

Reply

Gottardo DiGiacopo

10:34 am on Sunday, March 11, 2012

I had one child graduate from Mahwah High and another from Ramapo Ridge last year; they both recieved an excellent education. Many teachers in the mahwah schools impressed us as exceptional, and none ever seemed complacent, or bitter.

Being involved from home is critical to our childrens success. A simple mantra of "school first" (which i said/say to my children every morning) was a great aid in keeping all of our attitudes focussed on what was most important at school: their education. i personally was disappointed when a reasonable school budget was voted down in the recent past at the urgings of our then new governor. And the subsequent continued demonization of our teachers and their so-called-high-paying-much-time-off-easy-jobs is the most unfortunate untruth of this economic downturn, and the stubbon attitudes that plagues us all.

Most often the problem is how simple we believe the answers are... Perhaps we should start by asking better questions of the people devoted to raising our children's minds and character... An informed, productive discussion will quickly evolve from there.

Reply

Sr

10:52 am on Sunday, March 11, 2012

EDM when taught correctly is an amazing mathematics program. It spirals skills previously taught into the daily math boxes and through the games. I taught this program for 13 years and found it to be successful. As for the literacy component, I believe a balanced approach is best. First problem is that at a very young age, kindergarten, children need exposure to a full day program. There isn't enough time in the short session to really address the needs these children have. Parents need to to provide follow-through and let's face it, they don't! I, as an special educator, do and understand the importance of consistency. Phonics, shared reading, differentiated groups and a share out are the key components. To do this effectively you need at least two hours!!!! How is this done along with writing, mathematics and social studies and science in less than three hours? Not possible!!! What's really needed is a full day kindergarten, when you start with your younger kids, set the bar, and then continue the results will be higher than state standards!

Reply

Pete Malvasi

10:46 pm on Sunday, March 11, 2012

Wow. A retired teacher from allendale knows so much about the methodology of his friends in Mahwah yet the superintendent says she needs to hire a curriculum coorindator because too many Mahwah schools are doing different things! Really - what does she do? And why does it take a 80000 year coordinator to fix things there? Education system hasn't changed since Tenure laws passes in the 1920s - still inefficient and filled with too many selfish sanctimonious boobs.

Reply
Comment_arrow

AP

3:29 pm on Thursday, April 19, 2012

Pete - I totally agree!! It infuriates me to drop my child off at the Ridge and have teachers with "Stil working with no contract" signs in their hands - I go to work without a contract, as do most people. This entitlement to tenure and a contract is completely outdated. Teach children because that's what you REALLY want to do.... or get out. There are plenty of out of work teachers that would gladly take those positions.

June

10:11 am on Tuesday, March 13, 2012

FYI my son was tutored by the school last year at GW for the 3rd grade state testing. He struggled with reading and writing and was also taken out of class for the smaller based class with Ms. Simmon all year (which he needed). Upon moving to JK his extra help was taken away because guess what? He passed the state test as proficient. The school looked good because he was preped to pass the state test but he also still had his learning disability in reading and writing which JK wouldn't help him with due to the fact he scored proficient. Of course it took 4mths at JK for me to fight to get him his extra help back. I will NOT tutor my daughter for the 3rd grade test it will make the school look proficient!!! It just gears her towards passing a specific test that makes her look proficient!

Reply

Mercedes1

11:36 am on Tuesday, March 13, 2012

June...that's why all the tutors were hired! Old trick...at whose cost?

Reply

Ira

9:04 am on Thursday, May 10, 2012

Something is not right here. Just look at how much money we spend per student and you will see that our neighbors are doing a lot better with same amount of money. Throwing more money at the problem has been done for decades and has been failing over and over again.
There are a lot of good and dedicated teachers in Mahwah.
Problem is getting rid of those who are worry more about contract than teaching.
They are paid very well and have benefits that most of us can't even dream about.
All we want is fairness.
Don't blame it on the Fat Guy from Trenton.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Andy Schmidt

9:36 am on Thursday, May 10, 2012

There are two different issues - one is the huge gap between the three elementary schools (e.g. Betsy Ross vs. Lenape Meadows) in the number of kids that are NOT proficient by grade 3.

However, the OTHER issue, the "lack" of AYP (Adequate Yearly Progress) is entirely seperate and paints a completely WRONG picture to most parents, once you realize how it works.

Basically, it expects schools to BETTER their scores for the SAME grade EVERY year - making "adequate" progress. But it MEASURES that progress by comparing THIS year's 4th graders to LAST year's 4th graders. So - when Joyce Kilmer got a mix of students from the 3 elementary schools (with a wide range of ability!) last year and - and a fresh batch of DIFFERENT 4th graders THIS year - then AYP does NOT care if there was any progress from 3rd to 4th grade for the SAME student group - but wether THIS year's forth graders are better than LAST years.

Not only that. The "AYP" also looks as "subgroups". So if you have children with learning difficulties, or children for whom English is NOT the first language - then the school "failed" if THIS year's disadvantaged children didn't do any better than different disadvantaged children LAST year -- even if the vast majority (the "normal" learners - sorry for using that adjective) were proficient and met all requirements.

One can still learn something from the AYP - but only after realizing what it does NOT mean and that it might be specific to a certain GROUP of kids.

Leave a comment