patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices
Unknown

An Open Letter to Ed Sinclair from the Citizens and Taxpayers of Mahwah

Dear Mr. Sinclair,

Recently, you have been boasting about your personal integrity, honesty, openness, and looking out for the best interests of Mahwah taxpayers as reasons why you should be elected. However, the facts do not support you possessing any of these traits. In actuality, the facts directly fly in the face of those traits.

Consider the following FACTS.

We the Citizens and Taxpayers of Mahwah demand answers to these questions:

1. You currently earn over $100,000 per year as a DPW supervisor (mind you, not the head of DPW as you would want some to believe) in Mahwah. You also earned over $20,000 in overtime last year and have earned tens of thousands of dollars in overtime since 2009. You have publicly come against our Mahwah Police Officers earning overtime (who, by the way, only earned on average $7,000 in overtime last year). Does this sound like someone looking after the taxpayers in Mahwah? Why does a supervisor earn overtime at all? Is this the REAL reason you are so opposed to privatization of services in our DPW? Because you do not want to lose your overtime? How can you be against Mahwah Police earning overtime protecting our community when you earned more than three times what the average Mahwah Police Officer earned in overtime last year?

2. You are in the position of awarding contracts on behalf of Mahwah DPW. It is public knowledge that some of those contractors also did work on your home. Is this true? How do you justify this? At the very least, isn’t this a conflict of interest and an ethical issue? How does this differ from the recent North Bergen DPW Corruption Scandal that has been in the news recently?

3. You have publicly said that it is not the Mayor’s role to look out for the taxpayer and reduce taxes, as Mayor Laforet has done. If it is not the Mayor’s role, whose role is it? What is the role of the Mayor if it is not to represent your constituents and look out for the Mahwah taxpayer?

4. You have publicly said that you want to keep the tax rate “stable” and, on your website, you only mention taxes twice. The first time you mention taxes, you talk about long term stability in Mahwah's tax rate which many would argue is already too high (by the way, the tax rate was up between 3.14% to 26.67% from 2002 to 2011...7.21% in 2011 alone….that is stable???). The second time you mention taxes you say that Mahwah has enviable low property taxes. Mayor Laforet is trying to reduce the current tax rate and believes our taxes are too high. Don't you think we should be trying to reduce our tax-rate in Mahwah? How can you say our taxes are low when many Mahwah residents pay well more than $20,000 per year in taxes and have seen more than a doubling in their taxes over the last decade?

5. You have been seen driving around Mahwah during work hours in a DPW truck replacing your campaign signs post-Hurricane Sandy. Is that the best use of your time while many residents of Mahwah have no heat, electricity, are volunteering their time to help others, and are suffering? Should the Mahwah taxpayer be paying you to work on your campaign?

6. On your website and campaign propaganda, you list your priorities if elected Mayor. Budgets, reduced spending and taxes were conspicuously absent and not mentioned as priorities. With continued reduction in State aid, the 2% tax levy cap, pending Union negotiations, and the continued soft economy, why were those not mentioned? Are these not important?

7. You have said that your experience in developing budgets for DPW has prepared you to be able to handle budgeting for the entire Town of Mahwah. First off, the Director of DPW, Mr. Keith Hallisey (your boss) is the man responsible for the DPW budget. Second, the DPW operating budget for departments that you supervise was only 4.9% ($2 million out of $42 million) of the total municipal budget. Can you comment on how not being the person responsible for DPW (and their budget) and the fact that the DPW is such small percentage of the municipal budget has prepared you to be able to handle a $42mm municipal budget with a 2% tax levy cap? What educational or business experience do you have that makes you a budget expert?

8. You have repeatedly on the record been opposed to the recycling outsourcing plan proposed by Mayor Laforet for the following reasons: a). Loss of 6 DPW jobs b). Loss of 5 volunteers, which would cause disruption in our emergency services in Mahwah c). The projected cost saves are not real. However, you have continued to ignore the following facts: a). There would be NO loss of jobs. b). Disruption of emergency services is not an issue since there is no loss in jobs. c). Cost saves are very real since they are contractual in nature. d). Numbers were prepared and certified by Ken Sesholtz who you have publicly called the best Municipal Chief Financial Officer in the State. e). Mayor Laforet’s proposed service is much better than the current service-single stream weekly as opposed to multi-stream bi-monthly which we currently have. How is this an issue and why do you distort the facts? Is the real reason that you are opposed to this is the loss of OT that you are earning?

9. Blue Ribbon Panels have been consistently used around the country to get high quality advice from qualified constituents for free. Both Governor Christie and Governor Cuomo have employed similar panels to address issues in NJ and NY, for example. The Blue Ribbon Panel in Mahwah is composed of citizens who volunteered their valuable time free of charge. They are men, women, Democrats, Republicans, people that love Mahwah, but most of all, they were professionals who have hundreds of years of experience in running businesses, looking at budgets, taking a hard look at expenses, etc.  You have publicly stated that your "Blue Ribbon Panel" would be the Town Council. How does that reconcile with the checks and balances of our form of democracy (the Mayor as the executive branch, the Council as the legislative branch)? How is the Town Council a better advisor to you when: a). They could not even cut their own health benefits. b). The Blue Ribbon Panel was made up of independent residents/constituents who are only looking out for the best interests of Mahwah. c). The 14 members of the Blue Ribbon Panel have hundreds of years more experience than the Town Council? 

10. You have discussed in detail your economic development plan which centers around your "Come to Mahwah" advertising campaign featuring Ed Sinclair as the star (to quote you, like Mario Perillo’s “Come to Italy” TV Campaign). How do you expect to pay for this elaborate advertising campaign? Is this sort of expense prudent in these economic times?

11. Mahwah municipal elections and offices have remained staunchly non-partisan/independent for a reason. This year, you involved the Republican Party in the election and won their endorsement (interestingly with views that are polar opposite of the Republican Party that many of us are members of). Councilman Alderesio, himself a lifelong Republican, has renounced his membership in the Mahwah Republican Party because of their support for you. Why do you think the Mahwah Republican Party supported you despite your tax and spend views as well as your pro-labor stance and what role, if any, do you think political parties should have in future Mahwah municipal elections? Are you just a puppet and mouthpiece for people like Rob Hermanson who have their own agenda that is not in the best interests of Mahwah? Doesn't it make more sense to have an independent thinker as Mayor who only has one interest in his heart and mind, the residents of Mahwah? It is about time that we get some answers from you. It is time for a Mayor that REALLY exhibits integrity, honesty, openness and being on the side of the Mahwah Taxpayer. You are certainly not that man. That is why we support the reelection of our Mayor, William Laforet.

Sincerely,

CONCERNED CITIZENS AND TAXPAYERS OF MAHWAH

Chardel Vyjial

9:03 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Great Letter! Mahwah voters should read!!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mona Lot

3:59 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Go back where you came from AH

Thurston Howell III

9:03 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

This is why Sinclair refused to debate or take questions from the public.

Reply

NJR

9:03 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Great Letter to Mahwah voters!

Reply

J

11:13 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Please explain to me why this letter is allowed to be posted but the numerous ones sent not in favor of Laforet were never allowed to be published? I think the patch has proven which side they have loyalty to. I for one am disgusted how the Patch has handelled themselves.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Jessica Mazzola

11:22 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

J - Not sure where you are getting your information from, but it is incorrect. Below are the links to the only letter to the editor I received in support of Ed Sinclair, and a link to a blog post that a group posted in support of Ed Sinclair. All were posted on Patch, and still are.

http://mahwah.patch.com/articles/letters-to-the-editor-councilman-backs-sinclair-roth-digiulio

http://mahwah.patch.com/blog_posts/mahwah-republican-club-endorses-municipal-candidates

And, this is a blog post. Patch readers can submit blog posts here: http://mahwah.patch.com/blog/apply

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Tom Troncone

11:34 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Cite one. Just one. Frankly, I'm tired of this insinuation. We don't have a dog in this fight. Neither Jess nor I have a rooting interest at all in who wins this election.

Look, this is a really, um, engaged town when it comes to local politics. But here is what I can tell you ... I've heard from both sides, and neither is happy with us for different reasons that I won't get into. And that's a good thing in my book.

We're not going to be bullied by anyone. Period.

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Tom Troncone

11:37 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

And one more point, anything in Local Voices, we don't post, edit or have editorial control over. That's the blog section that belongs to the public. You could sign up right now and post the Gettysburg Address as a blog.

Comment_arrow

David Bagatelle

11:45 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Tom-I for one am happy with the objective journalism that the Patch and Jessica have exhibited. Thank you for being there and reporting it as you see it.

Comment_arrow

Andy Schmidt

11:47 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

>> I've heard from both sides, and neither is happy with us <<

And THANK YOU for that.

I hope you will continue to be add odds with both sides of any future issues that will arise. A sign of good journalism!

Comment_arrow

Lisa Patire

2:44 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Tom Troncone....Please don't refer to the situation as a dog in this fight. It is EXTREMELY upsetting and very inappropriate!!!!!! I volunteer my time to save pitbulls and bait dogs from fighting. Thank you for your understanding and compassion!

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Tom Troncone

2:47 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

@Lisa ... sorry if I offended you, it's just a figure of speech. I'm as big a dog lover as there is. Is horse in the race better?

Comment_arrow

Lisa Patire

3:16 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

@Tom, No horse in the race is not better. Many horses either die on the track or are slaughtered once they can no longer race. And thanks for the slap in the face!

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Tom Troncone

3:18 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Alrighty then, 0-for-2 on analogies I guess.

Comment_arrow

David Bagatelle

3:40 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

How about car in the race (although cars can certainly harm the environment)?

Thurston Howell III

11:24 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

J I think by 8:15 tonight when the results come in you will have more things to be upset about.

Reply

Thurston Howell III

11:45 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Lovie and I cast our vote this morning and put it in a bottle and floated it out to sea. I hope the tides get it to Mahwah in time.Gilligan was the only one to vote for Sinclair, all the rest of us voted for Laforet. Gilligan thought that if Sinclair won and he became the next "Mario Perillo of Mahwah" he would send a ship for us and maybe send us to Italy.

Reply

Thurston Howell III

11:52 am on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Tom you and Jess are the best! when will you start a unchartedisland.patch.com we have seven people here who have nothing to do all day...we would blog! Ginger would be great at it!

Reply

Candy Smith

12:30 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

I think that perhaps some of you have been ship wrecked on an island!!

Reply

lori dorie

12:30 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

are we talking about a mayor that has taked donations from the gas owners on rt17 in Mahwah and then turned around and voted "yes" on his planning board application!
this can all be verified thru election contribution reports and thru town planning board minutes....check it out for yourself.

Reply

Phil Lipper

1:13 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

No I think we are talking about the Mayor who stopped campaigning this week and worked his tail of to get power on in Mahwah. The one he kept the budget under control and has showed tireless leadership. I'm pretty sure that's the one we are talking about

Reply

David Bagatelle

1:13 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Ms. Dorie-First of all, please invest in spell check. Second, to see what your beloved Mr. Sinclair is all about, all you have to do is read my blog above. Case closed.

Reply

Bob Lockwood

2:34 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Who fact checked this posting? Check these facts out. You can look them up for yourself in town meeting minutes and on the NJ Elec website. Mr. Laforet's campaign has raised more than $52,000 this year with an additional $4,000 rolled over from last year, not including an additional loan of more than $5,000. One of our major concerns is "who" is he now beholden to with all of this fund raising? Here are four very disturbing facts: (1) $16,000 (30.4%) of his donations can be tied back to fuel companies seeking development in our town; (2) $15,500 (29.6%) of his donations are from people who do not live or work in Mahwah; (3) The Hoboken Chair of the Democratic Party is funneling money to Laforet’s campaign: $1,000 and (4 ) Laforet took contributions from a company that had applications before our Planning Board. He took the money and voted YES on the applications for a 24/7 Big Oil truck stop facing homeowners’ back yards.

Reply

Bob Lockwood

2:34 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

So why all of this 24/7 Big Oil money? So why all of this outside money? And why Democratic Party money? To view the financial details for both of our campaigns, go to this New Jersey State site: http://www.elec.state.nj.us (NJ Election Law Enforcement Commission). You can see the names of all campaign contributors over $300, as well as the amount they contributed. The Sinclair campaign promises you that Ed Sinclair is not beholden to any special interest group, other than the citizens of Mahwah. It doesn't look like the Laforet campaign can say the same.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eileen Rite

9:01 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Mr. Lockwood, I think you missed the point I made weeks ago; most of us do not vote party line especially locally, we vote for the person that we think will do the best job possible. We don't care who contributes what to who's campaign. Mr. Sinclair's main concerns were for the municipal workers and keeping the status quo. It was pointed out to me and I checked for myself... nowhere in any of Sinclair's campaign literature did he ever once refer to or even mention the Mahwah taxpayers, and I found that to be almost as disconcerting as your organization endorsing him. If he's the personification of a Mahwah Republican, then I just became a Blue eyed, Blue blooded Smurf of a Democrat!

Comment_arrow

David Bagatelle

10:37 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Ms. Rite, It's posts like this that make me proud to be a 20+ year resident of Mahwah. The silent majority won out over outsiders trying to take control of our beloved town. God bless you, Mayor Laforet and the residents of Mahwah Township.

Comment_arrow

David Bagatelle

10:37 pm on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

PS Ms. Rite, Thank you for fact checking my letter. As I said, nothing but the facts....Mayor Laforet was re-elected because of his strong leadership (look how he has handled the storm vis s vis other Northern Bergen County Mayors) and fiscal responsibility (he is already at work to keep our 2013 tax rate low, come in under the 2% tax levy cap, and reduce municipal waste and spending). Those are the issues that matter to our neighbors.

Thurston Howell III

2:55 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Mr Lockwood at 8:15 you will see what the town thinks of Sinclair/Hermansen/Roth
We are having elections on the island next year maybe the 3 of them can move here in time. Better chance of them winning here with only 7 voters.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jake Viscone

4:43 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Mr. Howell, Rumor has it "Lovey" threw her support behind Mr Sinclair, Hermansen and Roth. You need to have a talk with that woman, :)

Comment_arrow

Thurston Howell III

4:51 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Jake its just a rumor..lol....Ginger has a crush on Roth...The rumor she started was Roth was Eddie Munster grown up. Look at his picture ...is it possible?

Comment_arrow

Jake Viscone

5:47 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Mr H, I stand corrected! As far the Roth/ Eddie Munster debate, I think he looks more like Marilyn;

Comment_arrow

Mona Lot

7:05 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

wieldopher the man of many faces and names your finished for council nd the only reason your still envolved in this town is because your boy appointed you,hey enjoying The Captain? Have a good evening Thurston oxoxoxo

David Bagatelle

3:40 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

My Dear Friend Bob, Frankly, i am surprised that a man of your intelligence and education could support a candidate such as Mr. Ed. I have more respect for you than that (especially sine we grew up in the same place in Upstate NY). With that being said, you can come over to my house anytime you want (you have been at my house before and you know where I live) and we can through all of the documents supporting the letter. The facts speak for themselves. As far as Mayor Laforet's measly amount of fundraising influencing how he leads and governs our community....come on, that is ridiculous. I don't see Mayor Laforet using town contractors to do work on his house. I would add, that if I was running for office, I would raise money from my contacts which include contractors, builders, attorney's, CPA's, and banks, all of whom do business in Mahwah. Does that make me beholden to them? Of course not. Mayor Laforet raised money from people he has contacts with and since he is in the gas/oil business, of course he raised money from people in that business.

Reply

David Bagatelle

3:40 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

In hindsight, by the way, THANK GOD we have that 24/7 truck stop in our community because without it, our residents would still not have power. The Mayor used his contacts to allow O&R and other electric company trucks to refuel in Mahwah, instead of over an hour away in Ellenville, NY. I would also add that the 24/7 truck stop never ran out of fuel thus providing thousands of Mahwah residents a place to refuel their cars during the crisis. I know the truth hurts Bob. It will hurt even more at 8 PM when we no longer have to listen to this nonsense.

Reply

Ryan Price

3:59 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Wow, what an angry diatribe of slander, insinuation and distortion. David, you should get a better handle on the facts before you sign your name to it.

Reply

Bob Lockwood

4:11 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

David, Really. After all of these years, we are now going to make our political allegiance personal? Why bring up my intelligence, my education or where we grew up? That is crazy talk. Why this last minute desperate move to slander our candidate? Why bother with this if you are so certain that Billy is going to win. Your actions defy logic. Also, item #2; please provide specifics instead of slander (liable). Also #5; really. How about some details, dates, times, location, witnesses, sworn testimony. Come on. Let's stop the non-sense and let the voters vote. Do you really think anyone is going to change their mind or make-up their mind at the last minute based on a wordy diatribe. Come on. Your friend, -Bob

Reply
Comment_arrow

LKR

4:42 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Has anyone heard about a contract Mayor LaForet is designing to make Valero the municipal fuel supplier? That supposedly has been going on behind closed doors. if so, that will add to collusion and election contribution fraud. And if another truck stop
opens on 17 with the mayor's blessing why even bother with a master plan and beautification of Mahwah---gas station central !!!! And please do not draw the pain of Hurricane Sandy into it. We have enough fuel stations already.

Comment_arrow

Andy Schmidt

4:51 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

LKR, so your complaint is that the Mayor is trying to hurt his OWN business?

You DO realize that any "contract" has to be approved by the council? In the Mahwah form of goverment, called "strong council/weak mayor", the Mayor simply cannot do any of the things you claim.

Now, IF the COUNCIL reviews pricing bids and then awards a contract for municipal fuel to one of the Mayor's COMPETITORS based on lowest price, then I would be perfectly fine with this arrangement. Based on what I have seen through the past few years, they have consistently had the lowest prices (except for Pilot having better credit card prices).

Of course, I'm sure you prefer that the council should award the contract to a more expensive supplier?

Comment_arrow

David Bagatelle

2:05 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

When is the next Mahwah Republican Club meeting? Maybe they need to elect new officers...

Mona Lot

4:27 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

DB as long as we are at it your boy the mayor would not let the us postal service fuel their vehicles at "HIS" sunoco station I sure hope this didn't deter the elderly from receiving their medication in a timely manner,by the way DB most of the cars on line were from out of state,get your facts straight before you sprew your deceit,why wasn't your boys station open to everybody and not just a select few,ask about the DB

Reply

Thurston Howell III

4:42 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

@ML Sorry you can't come to the island with us..... you really do mona lot.

Reply

Hank

4:43 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

What a bunch of BS.
You post this letter a day before the election so the candidate cannot defend himself
Pure BS

Reply
Comment_arrow

Hank

4:52 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

The concerned taxpayers better get a good lawyer.

Comment_arrow

David Bagatelle

2:05 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

If Mr. Sinclair had come to candidates night he would have had the opportunity to answer these questions, but he didn't....I am sure he wouldn't have answered the questions anyway.

lori dorie

5:47 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Hey Mr Bag...guess you should also invest in spell checker. your 3:40 posting "sine we grew up in the same place in upstate New York". Can't wait for this election to be over...sick of all your mud slinging.

Reply

Wendel Stackpole

6:03 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

I think the mayor or his cronies who administer the Team Laforet page also need a spell checker the correct spelling is break, not 'brake' and bear, not 'bare. I guess nobody is perfect Mr Bag

Reply

Mona Lot

7:05 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

DB I certainly hope that you have positive proof for all the acusations you have made on behalf of your Mayor, I for one do not want to be included in your "Concerned Citizens and taxpayers of Mahwah" from Riovistaville.

Reply

Wendel Stackpole

7:52 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Mr. Schmidt,
You're just a book of knowledge and seem to have the answer for every comment made on the patch. Maybe you should have run for Mayor or are you just his mouth piece. I just happened to be driving down Miller Road and was stopped at the light when low and behold there was Mayor Laforet directing and guiding cars into his gas station when maybe he should've been more worried about town reidents getting their power back on instead of directing traffic into his station which happens to have the highest gas prices around town. Seems to me he was taking advantage in a crisis situation.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Andy Schmidt

10:18 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Wendel, thank you for your kind comments.

Roger Pachiderm

9:11 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

It's over the mayor won very comfortably. By at least 2000 votes

Reply

David Bagatelle

2:05 am on Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Blue Ribbon Panel meeting tomorrow...Who's in?

Reply

Regenbogen

10:58 am on Thursday, November 8, 2012

The voting is over and time will tell!

Reply

Leave a comment