Readers' Choice: Italian Restaurants In Mahwah

Vote for your favorite, and tell us why picked the restaurant in the comments below

Patch is starting a new feature of “Patch Favorites,” where you can vote on your favorite local business in Mahwah in a category presented each week.

While we came up with an initial list, we encourage you to post any businesses we missed that fit the “Favorite Italian Restaurant” category in the comments below.

Voting closes at 9 a.m. Friday. Ties will be broken by whichever business has the most positive comments below, and reviews on Patch Places. We will announce the winner at noon Friday.

The restaurants to vote on include:

Be sure to vote for your favorite place to enjoy Italian food around town, and tell us why it’s your favorite in the comments.

Editors Note: Because this poll is not scientific, it is not the sole consideration in choosing a winner. The winner will be determined by the Patch editor, based on poll results and reviews on Patch Places. Please vote only once per survey, per Patch.

Jennifer February 27, 2012 at 05:49 PM
We used to love Sony and Tony's however the last 3 times we ordered from them they delivered it to Ramsey. Each time I ordered we specified Mahwah and yet all three times the driver called from Ramsey asking where we were. Not once did I get an apology and on the last and final time we ordered we got the order an hour and hald later, cold. No discount no apology. I don’t care how good your food is, customer service is just as important!
Hank February 27, 2012 at 11:48 PM
It's a tough call. The Sonny and Tony Veal Parmigiana and Linguini and White Clam Sauce never disappoints. Those two are a slam dunk when you need a good satisfying supper in a hurry. I get it for take out all the time .But for Pizza I would prefer Brothers in Midland Park, Rays in Waldwick or Sal's in Ramsey.... just a matter of taste and where I am on the road.
Ann February 29, 2012 at 12:20 AM
Ann It's Sonny & Tony's for us. The food is great and the menu has many choices. There are also specials to choose from. We are never disappointed. The wait staff aims to please and they make you feel like family. Always fun and always good.
ref February 29, 2012 at 11:49 AM
Sonny & Tony,s is my vote for BEST Italian resturant
fastharry February 29, 2012 at 07:23 PM
I just happened into Mahwah Pizza Master about 3 months ago while at UPS in the A and P shopping center. I ordered a slice and was immediately impressed with the tomato taste and excellent crust. NOT over cheesy, not too thick, not too thin, like having a taste explosion in my mouth. I have been back several times over the past weeks to try other variety's. All very impressive. Oh Yeah, The meatballs are great too. Talking to the owner, I was impressed with his knowledge of cheeses and how they all taste different when cooked and paired with sauce. This place is AMAZING..and as a lifetime resident (72 MHS Grad), I am off Kinchleys after this place, LOL...BTW, I live 3 blocks from Sonny and Tonys...They have never been the same since the place was sold a few years ago. Got Comments?..Email me at support AT fastharry.com.
Mike March 01, 2012 at 03:54 AM
Nonna's, by FAR!!! Sonny and Tony's has gone down the tubes the past few years. Use to be great, no longer is. I think there's new management over there. Awful food, awful service. I've never had any problems with nonnas service and the food is how sonny and Tony's use to be. Best Italian cuisine in town, won't go anywhere else
Maria Cortese March 02, 2012 at 03:55 AM
Mahwah Pizza has friendly service every time I call for delivery or go inside. It's so tasty!! I had a chicken parm. dinner that was out of this world and I just recently tasted the meatball parm hero and it was extra good. I'm into food with taste and something that reminds me of mama's cooking! Go Mahwah Pizza Master! You are the masters of pizza!
Sal Russo March 02, 2012 at 04:02 AM
Awesome Pie, and chicken parm. Just like the Bronx where I'm from. I tried the soup a couple of times and they were excellent....right on point...It's hard to come by such tasty dishes like these!!!! Mahwah Pizza Master all the way baby!!!
henrietta March 02, 2012 at 04:13 AM


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »